What are the differences between the book and movie The Hobbit?
The Hobbit movies feature the White Council, with both Saruman and Galadriel present in Elrond’s home of Rivendell. However, neither Saruman nor Galadriel are mentioned in The Hobbit book, and the White Council does not meet during the narrative.
Is The Hobbit movie true to the book?
The mere fact that Jackson’s film includes characters, elements, or events that are “not in the book,” therefore, doesn’t prove that the films are unfaithful to Tolkien’s vision.
How close is The Hobbit film to the book?
As a novel The Hobbit is 276 pages in its 75th anniversary edition. The Hobbit as film is two hours and 40 minutes long, and encompasses only one-third of the book—and mathematically speaking, we knew there were bound to be some modifications.
Why are The Hobbit movies so different?
Both trilogies were directed by Peter Jackson, but The Hobbit doesn’t even come close to hitting its mark. There are several reasons for this including a change in director, a lack of preparation time, and the company’s insistence on making The Hobbit book into three separate movies.
What was changed in The Hobbit?
When Tolkien began work on a sequel (called The New Hobbit, after his publisher had roundly rejected material that would later become The Silmarillion), he changed the nature of the ring. Now it was a corrupting power, an insidious influence, and the idea that Gollum would happily give it up didn’t fit.
Why did they change The Hobbit so much?
The reason Jackson initially opted not to direct The Hobbit was to avoid the problem of competing with his Lord of the Rings trilogy, but if production had started from scratch after he did find himself in the director’s chair, or if the issues with del Toro had been resolved, The Hobbit may have been more on par with …
What was left out of The Hobbit movies?
The Hobbit Trilogy: 10 Things That Were Left Out From The Books
- 1 Azog Didn’t Exist. Within The Hobbit, Azog plays a big part in the movie, appearing as one of the main villains.
- 2 Radagast.
- 3 Bard The Bargeman.
- 4 The Eagles.
- 5 The Ponies.
- 6 Sneaking Away.
- 7 Bilbo & The Trolls.
- 8 Bilbo’s Appearance.
Is The Hobbit movie faithful to the book?
The first movie, An Unexpected Journey, contained bundles of nerdy references and was largely faithful to J.R.R. Tolkien’s original book. The second, The Desolation of Smaug, strayed a bit further from its source material, but was still largely Tolkien.
What was Thorin like in the book?
Thorin was capable of being stubborn, proud, and greedy. According to Gandalf he was, from the beginning, contemptuous about the notion that Bilbo should go with him on his long-desired adventure to the Lonely Mountain; he thought that Gandalf was trying to mock him and make him look foolish.
Who killed Azog in the book?
Dain Ironfoot
In Tolkien’s history, Azog was beheaded in the battle against the dwarves by Dain Ironfoot, Thorin’s cousin. If they wanted a recurring orc villain, they should have used Azog’s son, Bolg, who the movies reduce to Azog’s lackey and withhold introduction until movie two.
Did Thorin go mad in the book?
In the book, Thorin dies by what is assumed to be some stray arrows and he’s found dead on the battlefield. In the movie, Thorins death is executed beautifully. Filled with emotion and sadness, and it gives Thorin that one final moment of redemption for going mad and becoming an ass.
Why was The Hobbit not as good?
Easter eggs and callbacks to The Lord of the Rings were shamelessly forced into the unnecessary subplots of The Hobbit. The Hobbit falls into the pitfalls of the prequel by focusing too much on the past and not enough on telling its own stories. As the original, The Lord of the Rings didn’t have any of those problems.
Who killed AZOG in the book?
Why are Elronds sons not in the movies?
Elrond’s sons, Elrohir and Elladan
Some characters were left out because they would have stolen focus and screen time from other members of the Fellowship.
Was Thorin alive when Smaug attacks?
Thorin was still a youngster (aged c. 24), by Dwarves’ reckoning, when the dragon Smaug descended upon the mountain of Erebor in flames. Smaug left the mannish town of Dale in ruins and killed many dwarves who were inside the mountain. Thrór and Thráin (Thorin’s father) escaped using a secret Back Door.
Who ruled after Thorin died?
After the death of Thorin in the Battle of Five Armies, Dain becomes King under the Mountain. He redeems the Arkenstone from Bard with a fourteenth of the treasure, which is used to re-establish Dale. Over the next three years, Bard rebuilds the city of Dale and becomes its ruler. The city begins to prosper again.
Is Kili part elf?
TL;DR: Thorin is half-elf, and Fili and Kili are themselves both part elf and half-human. The two young dwarves represent the union of Elves, Men, and Dwarves that once existed before Dale fell, and which will rise again.
How do Orcs reproduce?
In The Book of Lost Tales, it is said that Orcs were “bred from the heats and slimes of the earth” through the sorcery of Morgoth. Again, Tolkien later changed this, as Morgoth could not create life on his own. This led to the most popular theory that Orcs were created from corrupted Elves.
What did Thorin say to Bilbo before he died?
Before he died, he made his peace with Bilbo by commending the Hobbit’s bravery and good character, apologising for his harsh words as he now recognised his comrade’s fundamentally benevolent motives. His last words were, “If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.
What went wrong Hobbit movies?
One of the main problems in adapting The Hobbit is that Smaug the dragon doesn’t fit the mold of a modern villain, being little more than a hoarder with a bad temper. To solve the problem, Jackson’s Smaug was more vicious than his book counterpart, and this alteration worked well enough for film.
Which is better LOTR or Hobbit?
There are two ways to analyze them: as standalone films and as adaptations of other works. As films, the Lord of the Rings easily beats out the Hobbit. As adaptations, the Hobbit movies just barely edge out the LotR movies.
Is Aragorn the son of Elrond?
In T.A. 2933, Elrond took Aragorn as his foster-son in Rivendell, and had Arwen live in Lothlórien with her grandmother. Elrond named Aragorn Estel (“Hope”) and concealed his heritage from him until he came of age.
Why was Tom Bombadil left out of the Lord of the Rings movies?
Bombadil is absent from Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings film trilogy; Jackson explained that this was because he and his co-writers felt that the character does little to advance the story, and including him would make the film unnecessarily long.
How old are Fíli and Kíli in human years?
(In the movie Ori is described as the youngest dwarf in the company, but in the books he’s older than both Fili and Kili.) Fili: Born 2858, making him 82 years old during the quest. Kili: Born 2864, making him 77 during the quest.
Is Thorin half human?
In Gene Deitch’s film adaptation in 1966, Thorin II Oakenshield was actually a human and a general and was one of three survivors in Erebor and Esgaroth along with ‘Princess Mika’.